Skip to main content

Texas has long been known for its tough-on-crime stance, which has contributed to its position as one of the states with the highest incarceration rates in the country. However, recent years have seen a shift toward reforming the criminal justice system to reduce incarceration rates and improve the processes surrounding the release of inmates. These reforms have significant implications for criminal defense attorneys, such as those at the DeGuerin & Dickson Law Firm, who are dedicated to providing the best possible representation for their clients.

The Shift Toward Criminal Justice Reform in Texas

Several key initiatives have been introduced in Texas aimed at reducing the number of people incarcerated and improving the release process. These reforms address various aspects of the criminal justice system, from bail reform and sentencing adjustments to reentry support and alternatives to incarceration.

Bail Reform

One of the most critical areas of reform has been the bail system. In 2021, Texas passed the Damon Allen Act, named after a state trooper killed by a man who was out on bail. This legislation aims to improve the bail system by incorporating risk assessments to determine whether individuals pose a threat to public safety if released before trial. The goal is to reduce the pretrial detention population, particularly for non-violent offenders who may otherwise be detained simply because they cannot afford bail.

Implications for Criminal Defense Attorneys

For criminal defense attorneys, the implementation of risk assessments can be a double-edged sword. On one hand, it provides an opportunity to argue for the release of clients who do not pose a significant risk, potentially reducing pretrial incarceration. On the other hand, it requires attorneys to be well-versed in the nuances of the risk assessment tools and prepared to challenge any adverse findings.

Sentencing Reforms

Texas has also taken steps to reform sentencing laws. These reforms aim to reduce the number of people incarcerated for non-violent offenses and to provide more opportunities for parole and early release. For example, Texas has expanded the use of specialty courts, such as drug courts and mental health courts, which focus on rehabilitation rather than punishment for non-violent offenders with underlying issues like substance abuse or mental health disorders.

Implications for Criminal Defense Attorneys

Sentencing reforms and the expansion of specialty courts offer criminal defense attorneys additional avenues to pursue for their clients. Attorneys can advocate for their clients to be diverted to these alternative courts, which often provide more favorable outcomes than traditional sentencing. Additionally, understanding the criteria for parole and early release can help attorneys develop strategies to support their clients’ cases for early release.

Reentry Support

Improving the reentry process is crucial for reducing recidivism and ensuring that individuals released from incarceration can reintegrate successfully into society. Texas has implemented several initiatives aimed at supporting reentry, including:

  • Educational and Vocational Training: Providing inmates with access to education and job training programs to equip them with skills needed in the job market.
  • Transitional Housing and Support Services: Offering housing and support services to help individuals transition back into the community.
  • Ban the Box: Encouraging employers to remove the checkbox asking about criminal history from job applications to reduce barriers to employment for formerly incarcerated individuals.

Implications for Criminal Defense Attorneys

Reentry support initiatives can be beneficial for criminal defense attorneys in several ways. Firstly, they provide a stronger case for arguing that clients will have the necessary support upon release, reducing the perceived risk of recidivism. Secondly, attorneys can guide their clients on how to access these resources, improving their chances of a successful reentry.

Alternatives to Incarceration

Texas has increasingly recognized the value of alternatives to incarceration for certain offenders. Programs such as probation, community service, and electronic monitoring are being used more frequently, particularly for non-violent offenders. These alternatives not only reduce the incarcerated population but also save the state money and often result in better outcomes for the individuals involved.

Implications for Criminal Defense Attorneys

For criminal defense attorneys, advocating for alternatives to incarceration can be a critical part of their strategy. Understanding the eligibility requirements and the benefits of these programs can help attorneys present a compelling case for their clients to be sentenced to probation or another alternative rather than jail time.

Legislative Efforts and Policy Changes

In addition to specific programs and initiatives, Texas has seen broader legislative efforts aimed at comprehensive criminal justice reform. The Texas Smart-on-Crime Coalition has been instrumental in advocating for policies that reduce incarceration rates and improve the justice system. Key policy changes include:

  • Reducing Penalties for Certain Offenses: Lowering the penalties for certain non-violent offenses, such as drug possession, to reduce the number of people incarcerated for these crimes.
  • Parole Reform: Implementing changes to the parole process to make it more efficient and to increase the chances of release for eligible inmates.
  • Decriminalizing Low-Level Offenses: Efforts to decriminalize certain low-level offenses, such as marijuana possession, to reduce the burden on the criminal justice system and focus resources on more serious crimes.

Implications for Criminal Defense Attorneys

Legislative changes provide criminal defense attorneys with new tools and arguments to use in their cases. Being aware of the latest reforms allows attorneys to leverage these changes in negotiations with prosecutors and in court. For example, reductions in penalties for certain offenses can be used to argue for lighter sentences, while changes in parole eligibility can support petitions for early release.

Case Studies and Success Stories

To illustrate the impact of these reforms, consider the following case studies:

  1. Case Study 1: Bail Reform Success: A client charged with a non-violent drug offense was able to be released pretrial under the new risk assessment guidelines. The defense attorney effectively argued that the client posed no threat to public safety and was committed to attending all court appearances. As a result, the client was able to continue working and supporting their family while awaiting trial.
  2. Case Study 2: Specialty Court Intervention: A client with a history of substance abuse was diverted to a drug court instead of facing traditional sentencing. The drug court provided the client with access to treatment and support services, leading to successful rehabilitation and reintegration into society. The defense attorney’s knowledge of the specialty court system was instrumental in securing this outcome.
  3. Case Study 3: Early Release through Parole Reform: A client serving a lengthy sentence for a non-violent offense became eligible for early release due to recent parole reforms. The defense attorney prepared a comprehensive petition highlighting the client’s good behavior, participation in educational programs, and strong support network. The parole board granted early release, allowing the client to rejoin their family and community.

Challenges and Future Directions

While significant progress has been made, challenges remain in fully realizing the goals of criminal justice reform in Texas. Some of the ongoing challenges include:

  • Ensuring Consistency: Applying reforms consistently across the state can be difficult, as different jurisdictions may interpret and implement changes differently.
  • Addressing Racial Disparities: Despite reforms, racial disparities in the criminal justice system persist, and more targeted efforts are needed to address these inequities.
  • Sustaining Momentum: Maintaining the political and public support for ongoing reforms is crucial for continued progress.

The initiatives in Texas to reduce incarceration rates and improve the release process represent significant steps forward in creating a more just and effective criminal justice system. For criminal defense attorneys, these reforms provide new opportunities to advocate for their clients, ensuring that they receive fair treatment and have access to the support they need to reintegrate into society successfully.

At the DeGuerin & Dickson Law Firm, we are committed to staying informed about the latest developments in criminal justice reform and using this knowledge to provide the best possible representation for our clients. By leveraging these reforms, we can work toward achieving the best outcomes for those we defend, ensuring that justice is served in a fair and equitable manner.